Questions tagged [scope]
Use this tag when examining what is on-topic or off-topic, and why.
263
questions
11
votes
4answers
107 views
Are Git workflow questions on-topic?
I recently started working part time in our organization's IT department and am working with one other person who has previously been the sole developer on several applications used in the office. We ...
24
votes
4answers
509 views
Reviewing “design”
It has been said in various comments that on Code Review we review code and not design.
I find this statement not very clear though. Obviously, if someone has an UML and not any written code, that's ...
5
votes
3answers
183 views
Are SSCCEs off-topic?
I was recently reviewing a question, which (if I had paid better attention to the question from the beginning, I may have noticed before answering) had a SSCCE as its primary code example.
At first ...
12
votes
4answers
175 views
Can working code be: off-topic -> not-working?
This question here: Shortest possible way of printing a specific board
Summary:
The code requirement is to print out a grid of text.
The code does in fact print the grid
The way it does that, is ...
12
votes
4answers
180 views
Off-topic questions that are still reviewable
There are some questions that are technically off-topic but still feel that the code really needs our help.
For example: https://codereview.stackexchange.com/questions/49347/tic-tac-toe-artificial-...
10
votes
2answers
70 views
Multithreading issue freezes the system - working code?
This question was closed as non-working code, in spite of the following, from the OP:
THe [sic] problem is that this implementation makes the CPU of the machine where the service app is running go ...
8
votes
2answers
66 views
Are reviews of protocols in scope here?
The rules for this 'exchange state quite clearly that discussion of
Higher-level architecture and design of software systems [...] is off-topic for this site.
However, I'm wondering if we might ...
18
votes
4answers
368 views
Should comparisons of code snippets be closed as “not seeking a code review”?
I've been seeing some "A vs. B" questions for a while, and I'm not sure if they're considered on-topic for this site. Many of these questions are not asking for a review, but which code snippet is ...
29
votes
4answers
1k views
Why is hypothetical example code off-topic for Code Review?
As stated in the Help Center, one of the criteria for a question to be on topic is:
Is it actual code from a project rather than pseudo-code or example code?
What is the rationale for that ...
9
votes
5answers
149 views
Make the help center more explicit about what CR is NOT
There has been discussion recently, about how lots of Stack Overflow users carelessly refer OP over here (CR) whenever the question roughly looks like a wall of code and OP is asking for help nailing ...
8
votes
1answer
69 views
Ask for review on JavaScript code style/structure, usage of patterns, and general quality of the solution
I have code I want to get reviews for. It's not a particular problem, and the code actually works wonders.
I just want to see what other experts can suggest in order to make it better, improve style,...
14
votes
4answers
217 views
Code requiring a third-party pre-processor to make it work
In this Wolves, Goats and Cabbages in Java question (here is a link to the pre-edited version), Java code is presented to solve the problem.
The code requires pre-processing by a third-party tool in ...
16
votes
3answers
219 views
Does this question belong on Code Review? Should it go to Code Golf?
I posted this question about how to rewrite a C# algorithm in fewer lines of code, preferably using extension methods, which prompted a discussion in the comments about whether it was appropriate for ...
11
votes
4answers
203 views
Revising or removing the “Best practices” topicality rule
In the Help Center, under What topics can I ask about here?, one of the rules currently states:
However, if your question is not about a particular piece of code and instead is a generally ...
25
votes
5answers
330 views
Do one-liners and other narrowed-down code qualify for a code review?
Every once in a blue moon, a question gets posted (often as a new user's first post) where the OP is asking a quite specific question about very minimalistic code, for example:
...
14
votes
4answers
100 views
Questions about documentation
Are questions about writing/improving documentation appropriate and on-topic for Code Review? And if so, should there be a documentation tag?
Let's be clear--I'm not talking about questions seeking ...
9
votes
1answer
125 views
What to do when working, non-example code is too much code?
In this question, I'm trying to ask about best practices for inner classes in Java, but it got closed because I only posted the code skeleton of the class structure and important methods.
The problem ...
14
votes
3answers
156 views
“How secure…” questions - Code Review vs. Information Security SE
Recently I have seen a whole lot of questions in the form of "How secure is this hashing", "How secure is my keygen?", "How secure is my form?".
We do have a quite popular security tag, with 159 ...
5
votes
3answers
88 views
Are questions on design only requiring minimal code off topic?
I asked this question which someone has flagged as off topic, referencing a question that referred to pseudo code as a reason. My question is in regards to the overall design and not changes to how ...
13
votes
1answer
199 views
What does it take to make code your own?
This question is meant as a general question, but it is also specifically about this specific question:
https://codereview.stackexchange.com/questions/39228/original-factorial-method-in-java/
It is ...
6
votes
1answer
57 views
Are these [performance] questions on-topic?
These two questions were posted by the same user, in August - the user joined CR around that time:
Capture with User32.dll or hook?
Encoding a screenshot to JPEG and saving it to a memorystream
Both ...
3
votes
2answers
92 views
Is this grossly incomplete code okay?
Shortening code to create a JFrame
The user has working code (I assume), but they haven't even started writing the logic for their game. They've just instantiated Java's version of a main window/...
4
votes
1answer
96 views
Does database normalization belong here?
As of today, we have four questions in the normalization-tag. One of these has already been closed, and the other three don't exactly look 100% on-topic to me as they don't include any SQL code but ...
15
votes
4answers
603 views
Questions should include a description of what the code does
Related:
What criteria do you use to upvote a question?
What makes a good question?
I feel that it is currently too easy to copy some code that you have written and put it up for review here on Code ...
1
vote
1answer
55 views
Reviewing unoptimized code in public repo. Are these type of question appropriate?
Currently I have a problem from a system that is not working properly (ref in Stack Overflow). It surely has many issues that might be related to both code optimization (PHP) as well as DB ...
4
votes
2answers
75 views
How can I make my question on-topic?
Connecting to Oracle using ODP.NET
I was told in the comments that it is off-topic, and someone has also downvoted it without any explanation.
I have shown code that works fine and want it reviewed. ...
11
votes
3answers
195 views
Could incomplete or not-quite-working code be suitable for review?
I've noticed that sometimes I end up reviewing code despite the question's violation of our policy that it must contain working code. I bring this issue up because it is related to Changing wording ...
9
votes
2answers
117 views
Is reviewing project structure on topic?
This is mostly related to the following two questions:
Web application structure review
I'd like to have suggestions about the structure of my web
application.
What the app does: My app ...
3
votes
1answer
39 views
“SQL sometimes times out” - on or off topic?
No question similar to this came up in the fancy box, so I am going to ask it so that it can be referenced.
Store Procedure Timing out sometimes?
It gives code that sometimes times out for the user, ...
6
votes
1answer
52 views
Codeblock detection
The idea jumped at me after reviewing two close votes in a row (granted, from the same user) that were homework assignments without any code in it.
Since a question that has no code in it (or one ...
15
votes
2answers
579 views
Should specific questions about example code be on-topic?
I've noticed some questions, like the following, come up:
https://codereview.stackexchange.com/questions/30092/map-then-iterate-why
Inheritance and forcing methods to be called inside another method
...
1
vote
1answer
71 views
Further action needed for non-working code that gets fixed here anyway?
This is in regards to Problem in calculating prime numbers in python
As you can see from the title, the post is only about a problem and not a code review. The issue at hand also seems to have been ...
7
votes
2answers
205 views
Is it okay to ask which snippet is considered the most clean?
Is it on-topic to ask a question with two more or less equivalent snippets, and ask which of the two snippets is considered the most clean?
The way I see it, there are four possible answers here:
...
4
votes
2answers
119 views
Off topic reason for questions that don't include code?
Currently, one of the two custom off topic reasons for CR is:
Questions must contain working code for us to review it here. For questions regarding specific problems encountered while coding, try ...
5
votes
1answer
57 views
Should the FAQ on off-topic questions link to other SE sites?
In the FAQ, there is a list of concepts that would make a question off-topic. It seems to me like this would be a great place to redirect users to Stack Overflow and Programmers, as what is off-topic ...
4
votes
1answer
131 views
Is example code on-topic?
From the FAQ:
I'm confused! What questions are on-topic for this site?
Simply ask yourself the following questions. To be on-topic the answer must be yes to all questions:
...
3. Is ...
4
votes
1answer
98 views
Move to SO or Programers
I can find it with a quick search; But:
But there must already be a question here on meta about moving off-topic posts to SO or Programmers.stackexchange.com ore automatic.
Like:
Off-Topic move to ...
7
votes
1answer
185 views
Confused between posting on Code Review, Software Engineering, or Stack Overflow
I have this questions that fits the FAQ of Code Review, Software Engineering, and Stack Overflow. It contains a couple code snippets for one platform and I'd like to know the recommended practice ...
13
votes
2answers
224 views
Can graphical notation count as code or should questions with exclusively graphical notation be considered off topic?
As a community, are we willing to accept graphical notation as a form of code that is subject to code review?
I recently answered a question that asked for review of a database model as presented in ...
11
votes
1answer
372 views
Is pseudo-code alright when asking about performance?
The FAQ states:
Is it actual code from a project rather then pseudo-code or example code?
But oftentimes pseudo-code is a lot more straight forward and easy to evaluate. It also applies to a ...
12
votes
3answers
226 views
Should we bother old off-topic questions?
Recently I've found some old questions which do not contain any code (usually just a link). Some of them have an accepted answer.
Since these questions are off-topic (according to the FAQ), should I ...
5
votes
1answer
156 views
Interview questions
It this a good site to ask others to review my interview question practice code? Or are you trying to keep it to "real world" questions?
14
votes
1answer
156 views
Are questions about LaTeX documents on-topic?
A few reasons to allow them:
I recently found that there are best practices and document organization methods. That is, splitting the documents based on sections, tables and so forth and using input ...
3
votes
1answer
200 views
Why is pseudocode not allowed?
Re: C# code to derive tangential points between two circles to create a trapezoid
I made the following comment, but since I will probably delete the OP (if I can), I'll post it here:
"With all due ...
9
votes
3answers
155 views
Is “how good is this encryption” in the scope of code review
I recently asked a question on Cryptography, that involved an encryption that I wrote. Usually, asking simply "how good is this encryption" would be out of the scope for that site.
my question: being ...
4
votes
1answer
96 views
Is a question mostly pertaining to build configuration appropriate for this site?
I'm currently creating a somewhat complex Maven project (specifically, to automate this answer), and hence would like to submit it for review here - specifically, the POM and the general structure of ...
12
votes
2answers
155 views
Are questions about public interface (API) on topic?
I'm writing some library code (ex. jQuery plugins, Django apps) that is meant to be used by other people as building blocks for larger applications. Often I don't see much need for others peer-...
14
votes
1answer
122 views
Code-correctness in the FAQ
As pointed by the poster of this question: https://codereview.stackexchange.com/questions/8609/dynamic-programming-algorithm-code-review, our FAQ states the following is on-topic:
Code correctness
...
